Bishop Mariann Budde spoke about “the culture of contempt” and responses to her message illustrated her point.
Out of Obscurity for 56 Hours
I write in relative obscurity. Jocelyn and I share stories of hope that we think are of interest to our REVwords readers. A good post might get 250 views in a week. 300 views would be in the exceptional category. Not the case with Friday’s post.
Over 2,250 people viewed and many shared the post on social media over four days. It set the record for the most REVwords views in one day over the last thirteen years. Someone said I touched a nerve.
The nerve was evident on social media. I didn’t reply to accusations made against me on my own Facebook page because those who know me best, respect me most. My beliefs, values and character need no defence. I am only saddened by the vitriol that my friends were exposed to. My finger was on the delete button a couple of times but friends advised me to let it ride.
I was impressed that a Christian organization let me know they used the post in a discussion with their staff.
This is a follow-up for our REVwords readers. I’m not posting it on social media. I want to keep the conversation on this site where we have maintained a healthy level of respectful engagement.
Words Matter
On January 31st I wrote about evangelical leaders’ responses to Bishop Mariann Budde’s sermon at the National Prayer Service for the President. My concern was for their effect on the souls of those who don’t know Jesus.
Already, many have written off American evangelicals and by association, Canadian evangelicals. There is a growing trend in the US that “evangelical” is equated with “Republican.” Americans Evangelicals are a voting block that helped elect the present President.
My post drew attention to the vitriolic statements made about Bishop Budde. My post shared their quotes verbatim.
Here’s a sampling of the criticism leveled against Budde and her gender, from representatives and spokespeople for Focus on the Family, Council for Biblical Manhood and Womanhood, Turning Point Faith America, the Institute for Faith and Culture, and others:
- “a false teacher who has no authority or right to speak in the name of Jesus.”
- “not a prophetic voice from the church, but rather pathetic.”
- “Women’s ordination is a cancer”
- “a woke clergy member”
- “a wolf in Bishop garments…. heretical, diabolical”
- “a reflection of the liberal sickness”
- “she used that moment to speak a demonic message.”
- “her sermon was indicative of the heresy being taught by mainline denominations.”
Bishop Budde spoke about “the culture of contempt” and the responses illustrated her point.
Informed
My favourite lines were quoted in ChurchLeaders – “It’s time for Bishop Budde to swap out her pulpit for a political podium. Her Diocese is in a death spiral. Average Sunday attendance plummeted more than 42% from when she was installed in 2011.”
Every pastor knows that if you want to land a blow below the belt, refer to declining attendance. Ironically, the Sunday services in her diocese on January 26th and February 2nd were SRO.
Many American friends (Bible College classmates, members of North Pointe who moved south), and some Canadians, sincerely helped inform me with their insights about illegal criminal immigrants in the States. We exchanged private messages on Saturday. I am learning.
Informed is helpful.
Surprise
During an interview about Budde’s comments, Franklin Graham said he was unaware of Trump’s executive order largely freezing the federal refugee program — a program that, according to faith-based refugee resettlement groups, also welcomes persecuted Christians. News of the executive order caught Graham by surprise.
“I wasn’t aware that this is under Trump, but if it is, I certainly will speak to that issue — privately,” he said.
Perhaps what he’ll say in private is what the Bishop already said in her public sermon.
No one who criticized the content took exception to the words of Christian leaders.
Because I commended the Bishop’s plea for mercy it was obvious I must also commend all of her other beliefs and behaviours.
Stand for mercy and compassion. You won’t stand alone.
We appreciate you as a REVwords reader and for the way you share your opinions here. All cool. Read on. And join the conversation and comment below. Thank you.
Hope grows here. We share stories that inspire people, build faith, and offer lasting purpose.
We’d love to have you Subscribe to REVwords. We’ll put helpful content into your inbox Mondays and Fridays.
Good Morning Pastor Bob…I wasn’t surprised by the comments on your blog. It is always “risky” to post comments on religion. No matter what…you are going to get divisiveness. I was prepared for people to lash out…but, to also stand my ground in what I believe in personally. I feel safe to be able to comment….without persecution with your blog. So, I did…and I got a person who called me out. So, when you call me out by name…and you don’t know me….I am going to defend myself…in a kind way, but firmly. This person did NOT do this to anyone else. I read another comment that voiced the same sentiments…and yet he did not point her out. So, I was thinking ….maybe he knew her…and didn’t want to rock the boat with her. Ironically, you posted your blog yesterday with a TedTalk…which I enjoyed immensely. To quote Father Gregory, “You can’t demonize people you know”. That sure resonated with me…after I responded to this person. I felt good about commenting on your page…since it is a safe and secure place. Thank you for sharing this with us. I always appreciate the stories and all the journeys that you share. Keep on, keeping on. As a rule, I never post anything pertaining to religion, politics, or money topics on my personal Facebook page. It is just asking for trouble. LOL! Have a great day! <3
Such a truthful quote, eh, Julie? Asking for trouble. The perfect 3-word description of engagement on social media.
I read your blog and scrolled through the comments, but like many others I chose to keep my opinions to myself as there is already so much divisiveness and apparently no room for civil discourse , even within Christian circles. Unfortunately social media and having our little computers at our fingertips so readily has seemed to given everyone permission to say things without thought. I appreciate you and Jocelyn so much and your constant challenges to us to be the light first and foremost vs being right always encourages me.
Thank you Bob.
I noticed my comments about Bonhoeffer came up anonymous. ‘Twas me :). Always quoting somebody, right. Can’t help it. Think I read too much.!
Act justly, love mercy, walk humbly before God … overarching words. Mercy triumphs over judgement and love really does cover over a multitude of sins. Those are not words of compromise but a choice to see who and what God sees.
There has been times when I have been asked about the people who are in our lives. That Laurie and I invite in. Although I had not heard the term before, a retired Pastor friend out on the Island described those that gather with us through a Life Group out on the Island. He called it an EGR group. Maybe you have heard the term? Extra grace required.
Well, don’t know about the group, but that is certainly me. Freely I have received, we ought to freely give.
I saw some of the replies you received on your post. I was stunned by how some God fearing people expressed themselves. Such unkindness to a fellow believer. After a while I stopped reading them. I know we are all going to have difference on many issues but with the presence of the Holy Spirit in our hearts we must be able to do so with love and respect. Unfortunately people being people this doesn’t happen at the best of times. Keep up your good work on RevWords .
Lillian! Thank you for joining the conversation for the first time. I tend to keep a low profile on social media as well. Thinking about how to engage in the future. Learning from others about the wisdom of when to comment and when not to. Thanks for leaning in and commenting today.
EGR. Yes, I am familiar with it and yes, it describes how you treat everyone. Love your quotes in our Youversion reading group. Alwasy impreessed with how you find a quote that perfectly fits the moment.
Hey, Dan. Thanks for leaning in today and the encouragement about REVwords. One good thing was people I had not heard from in decades re-engaged on the post which led to some healthy conversations offline. Most oif my friends are social media veterans with thick skin and can deflect the vitriol.
I respect and appreciate your insight and follow up as I struggle to make meaning and understand Gods plan amid all the current chaos. Thank you for your willingness to address difficult conversations and illuminate truth and the love of God.
Pastor Bob…I agreed with everything you said in the original post and agree with what you posted today. Unfortunately, social media isn’t about a meaningful discussion but about an opportunity to be hurtful if you don’t agree with someone. I doubt that people who post these alarming divisive comments would actually do so in person but then social media allows for hatred to be spewed and often anonymously.
Your opinion took courage to write, most often their’s doesn’t. Keep up your courageous efforts.
Ernie Pudwill
Thank you, TB. I see this is your first conversation in REVwords.Awesome! All through history, God’s people have had to deal with chaos and threats to their lives. It was truth and love that carried them through.God’s character of unconditional love, grace, mercy, justice, patience, goodness and kindness never change. I hope reading REVwords would be a source of life and encouragement to you.
Thank you again for joining the conversation.
Hi Ernie.
I was just talking about you on the weekend and sharing about the many times you stepped into harm’s way to protect the vulnerable and stand in kindness. You were a wise support to me in my pastoral role, advising how to take on criminals coming after the most vulnerable in our congregation. You are the courageous one, brother.
Thank you for sharing. Always look forward to hearing from you.
Thank you for the follow-up and everyone’s comments. As I get older, and hopefully wiser, I have stopped putting a lot of faith in the promises politicians make. My political decision-making, as in who I vote for, is based on the character and competence of the candidates.
Two quotes from politician’s at opposite ends of the political spectrum who both placed value on the doctrine of mercy,
George H Bush: We have a moral responsibility as a rich nation to not have people suffer and die merely because of where they live and the circumstances in which they were born.
Tommy Douglas: We are all in this world together, and the only test of our character that matters is how we look after the least fortunate. How we look after each other, not how we look after ourselves.
Great quotes, Retha. Good leaders knew how to engage mercy in a prosperous country. To whom much is given much is required.